Tuesday, August 02, 2005

The bare minimum

While the load on Ontario's power supply may not be going down, the supply itself is due to maintenance:
Four of the five units - nuclear power generators at the Pickering station east of Toronto and the Bruce plant on the shores of Lake Huron, plus two fossil-fuel units in Nanticoke, southeast of London, Ont. - were expected to be down for the day. The fifth, a Lambton coal-fired unit in Sarnia, was expected to return to service Tuesday. Several other units in the province also weren't operating at full capacity...

Tuesday's projected peak demand was expected to reach 25,400 megawatts, with the province only capable of generating about 23,700 megawatts, he added.

Constraints in those U.S. states that ship surplus power to Ontario could force the province to take more drastic steps, including brownouts and rolling blackouts, Young warned...

It wasn't immediately clear why several generating units were taken out of service but Young said it's not unusual for repairs to be required in a summer when generators have been working full out.

"You're seeing a system that is very strained," he said.

While it makes sense that some generators will need repairs after facing as great a load as they have this summer, there's no explanation as to why the system hasn't been planned to take into account for such readily apparent risks. But the answer to that can be found fairly quickly.

Today's Globe web comment includes the ever-fun spectacle industry apologists trying to make the case as to why Ontario is supposed to be better off under its privatized system. The comment claims that privatization will transfer risk from the public to investors...while conveniently ignoring the risk of power becoming unavailable entirely. This is the obvious risk of a system designed for profit: there's less incentive to provide any leeway, and thus more likelihood that peak demand totals will exceed supply. Just when it's needed most, the power most likely won't be there.

Of course, the comment does take time to lecture people about the need to plan added capacity. It conveniently neglects the time and effort that were spent planning the privatized system itself which could have been put to more productive uses.

All this isn't to say that the pre-privatization system was sustainable on its face: if rates were $2 billion per year below the cost of production, then the system was bound to run into problems no matter who was running the show. But there's no reason whatsoever why the now-higher rates couldn't have been used by a public utility to make added investments in the existing grid, without either the expense of privatizing or the risks inherent in a system designed to operate with a lower margin of error.

Now, power needs are soaring, the system not only can't keep up but needs to be shut down for repairs, and future projects to try to meet the needs are merely in a negotiation phase. Could continued public-sector management have worked out any worse?

The truth about Bolton

As weak as Bush looks being unable to get his chosen candidate through the Senate, the New York Times points out that it's an even bigger weakness that forced the Bolton nomination in the first place:
"Most of the reforms sought by the United States are well on their way to completion," said a senior administration official, speaking anonymously to avoid undercutting the rationale for the Bolton appointment. Another said that because so much had been achieved, there was little concern that Mr. Bolton's combative personality would jeopardize the agenda...

United Nations and American diplomats are predicting that the main challenge facing Mr. Bolton will be less to "reform" the United Nations than to convince his conservative admirers in Congress that recent changes are real, particularly those put in place after scandals in the oil-for-food program and in some peacekeeping operations.

So the sole reason for thumbing his nose at most of the world was...because otherwise, Bush couldn't count on his own party supporting his plans for the U.N.

Suffice it to say that this isn't the action of a leader working from a position of strength.

#2 (and climbing?)

Yet more evidence that when given an honest comparison, investors, tourists and others around the world like Canada just fine the way it is:
The Anholt-GMI Nation Brands Index, an analytical ranking of the world's nation brands, placed Canada just behind Australia in terms of brand power.

The group's second quarterly report surveyed 10,000 people on their perceptions of a country's cultural, political and tourist appeal, as well as investment potential.

Canada, a new country in the survey, bumped Britain out of the second place.

It was the second choice among countries for investment, immigration, people and governance, and third in the tourism category.

The one area of concern was a very low ranking in culture, which probably merits more attention than it receives.

But the most important finding from the survey is that despite a tax-slashing, regulation-ignoring regime to the south of us, Canada still ranks as a more attractive place for investment. (And in fact, the U.S. ranked 11th out of 25 overall.) Funny what a healthy, well-educated and hospitable populace can do.

Monday, August 01, 2005

Better information leaks out

The Washington Post notes that according to the U.S.' current estimate, Iran is a decade away from being able to produce nuclear weapons - twice as long as it would have taken based on the previous National Intelligence Estimate. No wonder Iran is willing to accept inspectors rather than completely isolating itself.

Of course, you wouldn't know the facts from Bushco's party line:
The carefully hedged assessments, which represent consensus among U.S. intelligence agencies, contrast with forceful public statements by the White House. Administration officials have asserted, but have not offered proof, that Tehran is moving determinedly toward a nuclear arsenal. The new estimate could provide more time for diplomacy with Iran over its nuclear ambitions. President Bush has said that he wants the crisis resolved diplomatically but that "all options are on the table."

The NIE, ordered by the National Intelligence Council in January, is the first major review since 2001 of what is known and what is unknown about Iran. Additional assessments produced during Bush's first term were narrow in scope, and some were rejected by advocates of policies that were inconsistent with the intelligence judgments.

One such paper was a 2002 review that former and current officials said was commissioned by national security adviser Stephen J. Hadley, who was then deputy adviser, to assess the possibility for "regime change" in Iran. Those findings described the Islamic republic on a slow march toward democracy and cautioned against U.S. interference in that process, said the officials, who would describe the paper's classified findings only on the condition of anonymity.

It'll take a frightening amount of chutzpah for Bush to try to push for regime change in Iran in the face of now-public intelligence stating that not only is Iran not a threat, but it's likely headed toward democracy without outside intervention. Unfortunately, there can be little doubt that the administration has a lot more chutzpah than competence.

Positive force

While the U.S. may be going out of its way to undermine the legitimacy of the United Nations, other states still take the U.N. seriously. Take, for instance, Iran:
Iran agreed late Monday to a two-day delay in reopening its nuclear processing plant here after receiving a request from the head of the UN's nuclear watchdog agency.

Mohammed ElBaradei asked Tehran for a "maximum of two days" to send its inspectors to Iran's nuclear facility where they can oversee the dismantling of UN seals, said Ali Agha Mohammadi, spokesman for Iran's Supreme National Security Council.

With observation in place, both Iran and the international community are better off: Iran is able to resume operations at its plant with somewhat less worry about repercussions, while the presence of inspectors will help the rest of us to know what is and isn't going on at the facility.

Which is good news for everybody except those who depend on fear of the unknown to impose their will on the world.

On basing policy on science

Precious natural resources are being lost because a government has not only decided to ignore sound science in favour of the unsubstantiated position of its donors, but also decided to harass the independent third parties who can demonstrate that its position is wrong.

Sound like Bushco on oil? Nope - it's Gordon Campbell on salmon:
The last report on Broughton, by a blue ribbon scientific panel led by Dr. John Volpe of UBC, traced the lice directly to the responsible fish farms and these findings were published by the Royal Society in London. They’ve been supported by every independent scientist in the world who is familiar with the subject, including Dr. Dan Pawley of UBC, named by TIME magazine as one of the top 50 scientists in the world.

What have the governments done in these circumstances? Notwithstanding the independent evidence, and having none of their own to contradict, they’ve nevertheless embarked upon a policy of harassing Ms. Morton, denying overseas reports and simply refusing to accept the independent evidence of our own independent scientists. DFO scientists, we have reason to believe, support the independent scientific findings but are suppressed by their politically controlled seniors.

The reaction of the fish farming companies is interesting. “There are no lice” they say until you point out that for years they have been using a highly poisonous compound, called Slice, consumed by the farmed fish, to get rid of this problem that doesn’t exist!

Rafe Mair suggests that the longer-term goal may be to eliminate wild salmon outright so as to allow rivers to be dammed. Whether or not that's the case, the science here gives an obvious answer to an important question: fish farms seem to directly cause damage to wild salmon, and all the diversion tactics Gordo can muster can't change that fact.

If only more media than the Tyee were making the fact known - but then that's what we're here for, right?

A handy suggestion

A quick note to Morley Watson of the First Nations University. While a task force to present ideas to improve a university facing bad publicity isn't a terrible idea, it might help to consult the people who are supposed to join the task force:
The appointment of a task force was seen as crucial to the future of the institution, which has seen a number of its top academics quit, and others asked to leave. Some have charged the board with politically interfering in the institution's operations.

But the first person Ducharme named, Judge Mary Ellen Turpel Lafond of Saskatoon, says she was shocked to hear her name mentioned, and she had not committed to sitting on the task force...

Board chair, Morley Watson later said the board may have acted in haste in naming Lafond.

Of course, acting with lots of haste (and very little apparent reason) was exactly what created the current mess for FNUC. As an institution, FNUC is a great step - but its potential seems on the verge of being wasted due to the current administration.

Accuracy in reporting

Yesterday, I pointed out that any media coverage of the trucking dispute would have to paint the companies as being in the wrong. I may have underestimated the ability of the dailies to euphemize their way away from accuracy in their headlines, even while the content of the articles tells the truth.

The Globe's headline suggests that the companies merely rejected "proposals", giving no hint that the proposals were from a third-party mediator...even though later on the story covers the fact of the matter:
"Since there is no deal, they are not going back to work," said Ken Halliday, a negotiator for about 1,200 independent short-haul truck drivers who have been on strike since June 27. The truckers parked their rigs to support calls for higher pay to offset the impact of soaring fuel prices.

Mr. Halliday said he was shocked by the results of yesterday's vote since transport company representatives were sitting across the table from the drivers when the terms were being negotiated.

"Now they are saying they can't afford it," he said.

And even the federal minister involved can tell which side has made some effort to reach a solution:
"The truck drivers have gone a long way to put their best foot forward and try to find a solution," Mr. Emerson said, noting his disappoint (sic) with yesterday's voting outcome.

Instead, the companies are now demanding a cooling-off period - presumably an end to the strike with no changes in the current terms of operation - while a task force examines possible solutions. Curiously, they seem to have left out any reason to think that the task force's findings will be given any more credence than those of the mediator.

The National Post's headline mentions that the deal was "scuttled", but doesn't point out who did the scuttling. The article then has some even more choice words from Emerson:
(Emerson) said the Ottawa had done everything the companies had requested to find a resolution to the dispute.

"Then they turned around and just gave us the finger," he said.

Now wouldn't that have been a catchier headline? Or for a more accurate one, wouldn't "Trucking companies reject mediator's settlement proposal" have done the job?

It's clear that the people paying close attention will know who's seeking a reasonable solution and who isn't. It's much less clear whether the public at large knows, thanks to the incomplete headlines at both national dailies.

Sunday, July 31, 2005

A minor issue

According to the New York Times, the Iraqi constitutional committee has resolved to finish its work by August 15 after all, at the expense of some of the most contentious issues. But it's the Los Angeles Times that points out what the most contentious issue actually is:
The key, when it comes to Iraqi politics, is the map. And what it shows is that in the Shiite Muslim south and areas close to the Kurdish north lie vast oil deposits worth billions of dollars per year. In the center, where most Sunni Arabs live, lie sand and scrub.

While other issues remain under debate, including the rights of women and the role of Islam, there is only one that could provoke violent upheaval: whether political power and oil revenue will be controlled largely by a centralized national government or by regional authorities...

One increasingly likely scenario is that the drafters, in their reluctance to confront the difficult issue and force a compromise, will put in vague language that defers the hard choices.

The effect of the forced deadline is to make it likely that the most contentious issue, the ownership of Iraq's most valuable resource (and perhaps only hope of rapid development), will be left unresolved. This may result in a plausible enough process to allow Buch to bring home some troops before the '06 elections, but it's obviously a recipe for civil war in the long term.

Which may be exactly what the administration wants: to get out as quickly as possible while claiming victory, then argue later that the civil war is completely unrelated to U.S. involvement and thus not its problem.

Show trials revealed

From a Kos diary: the Guantanamo trial process is such a farce that two different prosecutors consider it to be rigged.
The first email is from prosecutor Major Robert Preston to his supervisor...

"I consider the insistence on pressing ahead with cases that would be marginal even if properly prepared to be a severe threat to the reputation of the military justice system and even a fraud on the American people, Maj Preston wrote...

"(W)riting a motion saying that the process will be full and fair when you don't really believe it is kind of hard, particularly when you want to call yourself an officer and lawyer."

And even worse:
Capt Carr says that the prosecutors have been told by the chief prosecutor that the panel sitting in judgment on the cases would be handpicked to ensure convictions.

"You have repeatedly said to the office that the military panel will be handpicked and will not acquit these detainees and that we only needed to worry about building a record for the review panel," he said.

Not much to add that isn't in the article...except to say that it's a good thing the truth is out now, so that the review panels will be able to hear the full story as to just how unfair the process has been.

Cattle crisis followup

It may not count as a postscript just yet, but the CP points out a couple of the less-mentioned effects of the border closure.

First, Canadian cattle producers have lost enough equity in their ranches that they're now largely controlled by American interests. I'd be very curious how many of the new owners are the same member of R-CALF who argued against allowing the border to open.

Second, Canada's added slaughter capacity will continue to move processing northward, as even American cattle may be shipped here in larger numbers as a result of newer and better facilities. Good news for us in the short term at least, though we'll need to try to keep ahead of the curve in processing.

Third, our government's support for Canadian ranchers, while insufficient to allow farmers to actually maintain their equity, is about to result result in NAFTA challenges from American producers. Did we really need more reasons to follow Ian's advice and tear up the agreements that allow for this kind of insanity?

Just who's being unreasonable?

Yesterday, Digital Memoirs posted on the issue of the B.C. truckers strike. I was going to wait for DM's followup to respond, but today's events add a whole new dimension to the issue:
Truck companies involved in a dispute with truck drivers have rejected a deal that would have returned the Port of Vancouver to full operation.

The vote Sunday afternoon was unanimous. The port could have been moving back to full operation by Tuesday if the deal had been ratified.

About 90 per cent of the 1,000 striking truckers who haul containers had already approved the tentative two-year deal in a vote earlier Sunday.

DM had expressed concerns that the mediator was only involved in the process at the behest of other businesses, who had lobbied the provincial and federal governments to get their products moving again:
As always, big business wants these pesky glitches in profit pumping, called 'strikes' to end as soon as possible, and without change.

While this may well be true, the actual result of the mediation makes it clear just who's responsible for the continued strike. There's always risk involved where third parties are brought into labour disputes, but the more reasonable party should always be glad to have a neutral observer to validate its position, and in this case that's exactly what happened.

The truckers were willing to accept a contract recommended by a neutral third party in order to get back to work and also help the other industries who are affected by the strike. It's the companies who refused to accept a reasonable deal, leaving the truckers on strike even though they've voted for a fair resolution.

While the mediation process could have had negative effects, its actual role has been to make the respective merit of each side very clear to the public - something that may not have happened without the mediator's solution being on the table.

Now the battle lines are the truckers, the rest of the economy and the two levels of government who want to get products moving again, against the companies who refused a fair solution. No matter how thoroughly the media covered the initial arguments of both sides, that division may never have been as clear without third-party involvement.

Defending the Arctic

CTV points out that Hans Island is the least of Canada's sovereignty worries in the North:
The United States is challenging Canadian sovereignty in six other areas of the Arctic, including the Northwest Passage.

If sea ice continues to thin due to climate change, the Northwest Passage will eventually open up as a major shipping route. More and more, the U.S. and other countries believe that the Arctic waters are international waters -- as is the case in the Antarctic.

The article cites some efforts now being made to patrol the Arctic, which certainly helps matters somewhat.

But as few as one or two successful trips through the Northwest Passage by other states could take away Canada's sovereignty under international law, effectively gutting any capacity to monitor environmental compliance by foreign ships. In turn, foreign use of the Passage might lead to settlements which could come under foreign control, ultimately undermining Canada's authority over the Arctic.

I'm not a hawk on most military issues, but the stakes in this one are massive, and Canada's general knowledge of the problem is sorely lacking. The current steps are a start, but they're far from enough...and Hans Island, while perhaps worth paying attention to, shouldn't be the top story among northern issues.

(Edit: typo.)

By the numbers

StatsCan is an absolutely vital piece in our ability to understand the current position of Canada and the people inside it. Which makes stories like this particularly disturbing:
The erroneous data on Canada's 2004 trade in cultural goods, such as CDs and videos, were first placed on the Statistics Canada website March 29.

The agency then posted a correction to the material May 19, and alerted users to the corrected numbers in a website notice five days later...Trouble is, the so-called corrected numbers were themselves incorrect.

By June 10, Statistics Canada had verified that its correction indeed needed correcting.

But internal dithering and red tape prevented the agency from dealing with the problem until June 21, when it finally withdrew the bad numbers from the website and posted an apology...

A spokesman for the agency said the problems began when a programmer developed new software, then left for another job.

A second programmer took over, but "obviously, (the software) was not tested properly," Francois Nault, director of Culture, Tourism and the Centre for Education Statistics, said in an interview.

While it's a plus to have timely numbers, it's all the more important that they be accurate...and in particular that the current contents of StatsCan's publicly-available material reflect the best current knowledge. This incident suggests that StatsCan currently doesn't have enough coordination either internally, or with the other organizations that gather data.

Not making progress

It hasn't taken long for the U.S.' conditions for Iraq withdrawal to be declared unreachable:
Key members of the committee writing the new Iraqi constitution said Sunday they need another month to finish the draft, threatening U.S. efforts to maintain political momentum to combat the insurgency...

Mr. Talabani met with U.S. Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad and afterward insisted the deadline must be met. Mr. Talabani, a Kurd, began urgent consultations with parliament leaders to head off a delay...

Under the original deadline, the National Assembly had until Aug. 15 to approve the charter and submit it to a national referendum in mid-October. That formula was strongly supported by the Americans.

But major differences remain among the ethnic and religious groups represented on the committee, including disputes over such issues as federalism, dual nationality and the role of Islam.

In sum:

The only thing that the constitutional drafters have agreed on so far is that they need more time to actually reach a workable agreement. But the U.S., having decided that some arbitrary timetables are entirely to its liking, wants whatever the committee can produce by mid-August, regardless of whether or not all (or any) ethnic groups are satisfied with it.

Somehow this doesn't strike me as a recipe for stability. Not that anything the U.S. has done in Iraq can be classified as that.

Saturday, July 30, 2005

Reaching out

While most of the recent trend has been toward more stringent immigration requirements, the Ukraine is encouraging a wide group of people to visit:
Ukraine said it was scrapping visas for Canadians from August 1 and extending visa-free travel for travelers from the European Union as part of President Viktor Yushchenko's plan to move closer to the West.

A presidential decree posted on his Website said visas would no longer be required for Canadian visitors coming into Ukraine for less than 90 days.

Another decree on the same site said visa-free travel for citizens of the EU countries and Switzerland would be extended beyond the initial deadline of Sept. 1.

The effect of the earlier EU pilot project was to double EU tourism, for obvious reasons.

While we should try to coordinate with the U.S. to the greatest degree possible and preserve security at our borders, Canada should also do everything possible to reciprocate the Ukraine's actions toward a free flow of people, and to encourage similar measures worldwide. In the long term, any threat posed by the particular people travelling will be more than outweighed by the erosion of ethnocentrism.

Career opportunities

Reuters notes that politicians and diplomats moving to the private sector are finally coming under some scrutiny:
Boards need fewer super-star directors who sport prestigious resumes but lack financial expertise, governance experts argue. They say the corporate scandals of recent years show that boardrooms should be filled with seasoned business people who can sift through complex financial matters.

"When you go from (being) a member of Congress to a board you better know finance and accounting," said Roger Raber, head of the National Association of Corporate Directors, an education and research group. "I suspect a lot of people from the Hill don't have finance and accounting backgrounds."...

The financial gains that ex-government officials reap from board service also can leave bad tastes in the mouths of investors who see potential conflicts of interest.

Former New York City police commissioner Bernard Kerik, who sat on the board of stun gun maker Taser International Inc., realized about $6.8 million from the sale of stock options.

You'd think that directors with little relevant experience and obvious potential for conflicts of interest would inherently be in very little demand. So far, the allure of big name directors has outweighed those concerns, but with enough attention to the process that could change.

Of course, it would help if the article actually pointed out the most obvious recent example of corporate/government overlap, but apparently Dick Cheney was out of bounds. Instead, the lesson for now seems to be that if you move among high enough positions, you'll escape the criticism given to everybody else.

Disclaimer

CNN notes that Bush has been proclaimed physically "fit for duty" after a physical. It leaves out the disclaimer that I can only presume was given by the examining physicians:

WARNING

The within opinion is based purely on a physical examination of the subject. The phrase "fit for duty" refers only to the capacity of the subject's body to withstand the remainder of the expected term of office, absent external shocks or successful grenade throws. We emphasize our opinion that subject should avoid bicycles, Segways and pretzels to the extent possible.

This opinion further makes no comment on the subject's mental capacity to engage in the duties required of his office, nor on any mental health concerns raised by the scope of the subject's work.

In particular, we suggest that the following potential concerns be closely monitored:
(1) subject's stress level, due to past comments about the difficulty of his work and due to recent polling numbers suggesting mutual dissatisfaction between subject and his employers; and,

(2) subject's level of mental activity, due to past difficulty with language.

This opinion in no way warrants the subject's fitness to continue should he cease to take vacations of the length historically taken. Nor does it warrant that subject is fit for duty for any period extending beyond his expected term of office, due to a declaration of martial law or any other reason.

Thinking ahead

Jim Elve posts on the Next Great Prime Minister contest.

This does appear to be an upgrade on the former As Prime Minister essay contest, since we should all be aware that true potential leaders don't stoop to writing their own policy ideas. I just wonder whether there will be a parallel Next Great Prime Ministerial Advisor contest for whoever most helps out the winner.

While it's obviously going to have its circus-like elements, good on Magna for getting a start on evaluating a future generation of politicians. In a couple of decades, if the planning goes well enough, maybe we'll be able to avoid speculation about people like these becoming PM.

Private-sector waiting lists

For those assuming that private-sector delivery automatically results in faster and better service (whether in health care or elsewhere), the Tyee has an important counterexample:
Maximus, the U.S. company in charge of BC’s Medical Service Plan (MSP) and PharmaCare, is being fined for the second time this year after failing to uphold a requirement of their contract with the BC government. The company must maintain a three minute waiting time for people calling in to the automated services. Currently, the waiting time is five times that much, at fifteen minutes per call...

Because employees of the two programs both work with the phone lines and conduct paper work, mailed applications are slowing down as well. According to the Times, in June, 62 per cent of new applications for MSP were processed within 40 days. In 2004, that number was 64 per cent. Both are far behind the Maximus target, which was 99 per cent within 20 days.

As an added bonus, Maximus is also under investigation in Washington, D.C. and has "had problems" in six states...yet is in the running for another of Gordo's privatization programs, this time for BC Nurseline.

The lesson to take from this is of course that privatization itself doesn't do anything to lessen the burdens on the health system - that can only be accomplished through new (and properly targeted) resources, regardless of their source. Meanwhile, the transaction costs of privatizing only distract attention from the real problems. BC is caught in that trap now; other provinces should learn from Campbell's mistakes.

(Edit: eliminated superfluous and unnecessary redundancy.)

Friday, July 29, 2005

Democracy is for sale

The New York Times may be doing a fairly miserable job addressing the corruption in its own country, but it does have an interesting piece on the effect of corruption in Latin America:
The shift from authoritarian governments to democracies, many had hoped, would squelch the kind of corruption that predominated when dictators ran the affairs of state to the benefit of a small clique of insiders and threatened whistle-blowers.

Yet successor governments across the political spectrum, whether free-market advocates like Mr. Toledo or self-proclaimed leftists like Mr. da Silva, have proved even more susceptible. With once-closed economies having been opened up and corporate profits at record levels, the opportunities for graft and bribes are larger than ever.

So widespread is the disgust that last year another regionwide poll found that a majority of Latin Americans would prefer a return to dictatorship if it would bring economic benefits. Despite improved economic indicators since then, the ranks of the poor have continued to swell, as has the resentment of those who are pocketing the wealth of the nation for their own benefit.

Needless to say, this is a terrible development for democracy and for social equality across the hemisphere - regardless of one's place on the political spectrum, there can be no doubt that corruption takes resources away from where they can do good and redirects them into an cycle of abuse.

But then, can the U.S. claim to be doing any better, particularly when the article makes statements like these?
Corruption shows itself in many ways, but perhaps its most glaring and grating form is nepotism and patronage, the flaunting of political connections that so alienates ordinary people. Those practices also take many forms, from outright bribes to jobs and contracts awarded to unqualified or inexperienced people who happen to be related to those in power...

Perhaps most ominous for the region's democratic health is that recent scandals...involve corruption not simply for personal enrichment, but also to obtain and hold onto power indefinitely, threatening democratic institutions themselves. Yet the leaders involved have denied wrongdoing and have been loath to accept any responsibility.

Does that sound like anybody you may have heard of recently?

Of course, in addition to Bushco, it also applies at least in part to Liberal operatives as revealed by Gomery. Sadly, there are strong built-in incentives for parties to play the system for all it's worth in the immediate election - particularly when the effect is for a sitting government to keep the opposition out of power (and away from the books) for another term.

Unfortunately, the Times' focus on elsewhere leaves out the most important lesson to be taken from the article. Corruption isn't just a problem for some other country a continent away to worry about when it's not developing as quickly as hoped. Rather, it's a constant danger which all governments, parties and citizens need to watch out for - and need to recognize as something to be changed, not something to be covered up.

Ground rules

Kos points out just how complicit the media has been in Bushco's selective and self-serving leaks. No wonder even Coulter and O'Reilly can't pretend that the media is anywhere but in Bush's hip pocket these days.

Comparative spending

Due credit to the National Post for this article:
Ottawa has allotted more than $10 billion for enhanced public safety since the 9-11 attacks in New York, while thousands die from air and water pollution.

"I think we're investing a lot of money on feel-good programs, that we could be saving a lot more lives in some of our environmental problems," said David Schindler, a prominent ecology professor at the University of Alberta.

He said far more people are killed by air and water pollution than by terrorism, citing an estimate by the American Microbiological Society that 100,000 Americans die annually due to waterborne disease.

"That translates into about 10,000 (Canadians) sickened by plain old pathogens, nothing that a terrorist puts into our water supply. The terrorists are us, you might say."

Stop by and leave a comment - this is in the "Sound Off" section, and right now the comments are about evenly split between those approving of such obvious truths, and those putting in a stubborn effort to avoid any sense of proportion.

Spend, spend, spend or save, save, save?

Many people will be aware, and perhaps more should be aware, of the state of politics in Saskatchewan. While the right-wing opposition Saskatchewan Party is calling for tons of spending out of the government's current surplus, the NDP government is taking a cautious approach:
Finance Minister Harry Van Mulligen released the government's first-quarter financial report Thursday showing a projected $255-million in additional revenue for the year, with $201 million from oil alone...

That leaves another $116 million in extra cash -- for now being used to lower the draw-down on the rainy-day fiscal stabilization fund -- but Van Mulligen said the government will likely wait until its mid-term report is released in November before it makes further commitments of cash.

"In terms of surplus dollars and how we would allocate those, I think it's important to look at where we were in mid-term last year where we said 'okay, we have additional revenues, what is our plan?' Our plan was one, permanent debt reduction. Another part of our plan was permanent infrastructure -- both government-owned infrastructure and third-party capital needs ... we also looked at the question of tax reduction," he said in a press conference at the provincial legislature.

"And we always have pressures every fiscal year that we need to fund."

It's hard to come up with a more sensible approach than that, and the Sask Party isn't anywhere near up to the task - their current argument is that the government should have a long-term plan to deal with short-term revenue which is based on uncertain factors, while ignoring the fact that debt reduction is the most important long-term plan a government can have.

The current provincial situation aside, the Saskatchewan NDP's approach is one that the federal NDP should be taking strongly going into the next election. Rather than the 33%/33%/33% model for tax cuts, program spending and debt reduction that has been emphasized by both the provincial NDP circa Romanow and by the current federal Liberals, the federal NDP should follow Van Mulligen's lead and make debt reduction the first priority based on its obvious impact on the ability to deliver the other two. Spending can also be increased slightly, with enough targeted tax cuts to pursue likely voters.

Making the party's platform split something along the lines of 10%/40%/50% will allow the NDP to present itself as both the best provider of needed spending, and by far the best fiscal steward, leaving the Cons and Libs to fight over the CTF vote. It may be tough to get such a message through the media, but it's one that Canadians can understand given the opportunity.

If there's an issue that can make the NDP into the most viable federal fiscal manager, this is the one. Let's run with it.

Thursday, July 28, 2005

Open to uncertainty

We're still not sure whether or not most of Bushco will take "I don't know" for an answer. (For that matter, anything other than "Thank you sir, may I have another?" seems to be problematic.) But American intelligence services are being instructed to say just that when appropriate:
John D. Negroponte, the new director of national intelligence, has imposed strict safeguards intended to ensure that the government's National Intelligence Estimates are based on credible information instead of the kinds of unsubstantiated claims that were the basis for prewar intelligence on Iraq, his top deputy said Thursday...

General Hayden acknowledged Thursday that the new precautions were likely to result in estimates that proved much less definitive than in the past. But he said he and Mr. Negroponte would embrace "a higher tolerance for ambiguity" than had been accepted and would encourage analysts to be forthright about what they did not know...

Other government officials said the standard had already been applied, to a recent highly classified intelligence report on Iran, producing findings that the officials described as infused with considerable uncertainty about the status of Iran's nuclear weapons program.

It's especially interesting to hear this applied to Iran specifically; the explicit doubt (make a note of it for later) should make it much tougher for Bushco to try to force a war there later on.

There's no word yet on whether Bush already regrets appointing Negroponte. But if this order is actually going to be acted upon (and some skepticism is called for at this point), then reality may play a significantly larger role in Bush's lame-duck years than it's played so far in the administration.

From the Department of the Blindingly Obvious

According to the Washington Post:
Efforts to rebuild water, electricity and health networks in Iraq are being shortchanged by higher-than-expected costs to provide security and by generous financial awards to contractors, according to a series of reports by government investigators released yesterday.

(I)n March, the U.S. Agency for International Development canceled two electric power generation programs in order to provide $15 million in additional security elsewhere. On another project to rehabilitate electric substations, the Army Corps of Engineers decided that securing 14 of the 23 facilities would be too expensive and limited the entire project to nine stations. And in February, USAID added $33 million to cover higher security costs on one project, which left it short of money to pay for construction oversight, quality assurance and administrative costs...

Despite $5.7 billion committed to restoring electricity service in Iraq, power generation was still at lower levels as of May than it had been before the U.S. invasion in 2003. In one case, the GAO reported, the United States led an overhaul of an Iraqi power plant but then did not adequately train the Iraqis how to operate it. A widespread power outage resulted.

Crude oil production has also dropped in the past two years, even with more than $5 billion in U.S. and Iraqi funds available for rebuilding. Oil export revenues are needed to fund more than 90 percent of the nascent Iraqi government's 2005 budget, the State Department has said.

None of this should be particularly new. But the excessive amount of money being put into contractors' pockets (whether security or otherwise), combined with resources being cut from the actual programs which could help Iraqi citizens, is only cementing negative perceptions of the occupation. This may not be a problem for an administration which so easily ignores its detractors, but it'll only make life worse for whoever gets to clean up the mess.

Don't write this one off

Scott Piatkowski has some good advice for anybody applying to become Paul Martin's new speechwriter:
Hyperbole is a good substitute for action. For example, the more that the Prime Minister seems paralyzed by the thought of actually making a decision, the more important it is that his speeches trumpet phrases such as “transformative change.” Achieving actual transformative change is not your department...

Recycling can save time. Martin made some great promises on housing in 1990. He made some great promises on combatting global warming in 1993. He spoke bravely about fighting two-tier health care in 2003 and 2004. Since these and other promises have not been honoured, it's completely permissible to dust them off and make them again.

All too true. Give it a read.

Elections and legitimacy

Unlike in one conspicuous neighbouring country, any known problems with elections in Canada have fallen short of completely altering the end result. But that doesn't mean there isn't a need to make sure the process is handled carefully, if B.C.'s recent provincial election is any indication:
Mayencourt’s 11 vote victory, Stevenson argued, was the result of a screw-up by elections officials that had left 71 absentee ballots improperly certified and thus uncounted. On June 20 Stevenson asked the BC Supreme Court to throw out the election and call a new one...

Eleven of the uncounted ballots were from incomplete certification envelopes. According to Porayko the envelopes had names, addresses and everything else, but hadn’t been signed. Whether that’s because the voters forgot to sign, or were never told to, we’ll never know.

The other 60, however, were never put in envelopes in the first place. On May 17, 60 misplaced voters turned up at St John’s United Church on Comox and Broughton, in the heart of the West End. Rather than have them fill out certification envelopes, an official working at the station stuck their ballots in with the rest from St John’s. When the District Electoral Officer found out, he immediately had the ballots taken out and set aside.

Because the mystery 60 had never filled out certification envelopes, there was no way to verify that they are who they claim, that they live in the riding and that they hadn’t already voted. On this point, the Elections Act is clear, a non-certified ballot cannot be counted, Porayko said. “As administrators we didn’t write the Act but we have to follow it,” she said. And following the act meant not counting the 60 ballots.

Stevenson has dropped his challenge in order to run again for City Council. And the Liberals won by enough of a margin that it wasn't a life-or-death struggle for the parties involved.

But imagine if the same scenario were to come up in an election with a configuration similar to the last federal one (or for that matter the last Saskatchewan one). While it's always tough to see the need for action when nobody's contesting the last results, it's imperative that election workers are impeccably trained to avoid errors like the one in Vancouver-Burrard - because eventually, it will make all the difference.

Complicity through silence

From the Halifax Herald, a startling discovery:
Craig Botterill, the Crown attorney who handles such prosecutions for the province, said banks report only a fraction of debit and credit card crimes.

They are reluctant to jeopardize the hefty profits they earn from diverting business to electronic services from tellers, the prosecutor said.

"They're quite content to cover the losses in-house and not report most thefts..."

Canadian banks claim debit card scams cost them about $60 million last year, and credit card scams $163 million. But Mr. Botterill suspects the actual figures are much higher. He has heard of banks trying to keep quiet about single scams amounting to as much as $80,000.

The long-term effect of the failure to report these incidents is of course harmful for both the banks and the customers. Offenders are less likely to be caught by the bank investigation alone, and won't face criminal sanctions even if caught. Hence there's less cost to engaging in this type of fraud, and less deterrence against it. And in addition to the harm to additional victims in the future, there's also less than full recompense to the individual victim, who is effectively told that the breach of privacy is irrelevant.

If this story breaks strongly enough, then banks won't have much to gain by failing to report incidents. The public will be on notice as to the scope of the crimes, and any suspicions as to the scope of undisclosed crime will make for a strong incentive to show that all losses are being reported. Concerns over public fear would then turn in favour of reporting rather than against it.

So, pass the story along...and be all the more careful with your own information, because for now, your bank may not see its theft as worth reporting.

NHL attention down south

The good news: prominent Americans are publicly paying close attention to hockey.

The bad news: those prominent Americans are congressmen determined to impose a draconian and ineffective drug-testing regime in the NHL along with other leagues.
A bill introduced in May by Davis, Waxman and Arizona Republican Senator John McCain would suspend offending players for two years for a first offence and ban them for life if they fail a second drug test...

While Davis and Waxman also criticised the NHL's drug program because it doesn't consider "designer" steroids — created in a lab specifically to evade detection — it's unfair to suggest that the league could create a program free of loopholes, Collins said.

"Human-growth hormone has been a popular performance enhancer for two decades but a reliable test to detect its presence in urine remains elusive," he said.

The fact all too often left out of articles on steroid testing is that the tests themselves are based on ratios of naturally-occurring substances within the body, meaning that some players with a naturally-high testosterone level (or who have merely trained particularly well) will test positive despite having not taken a performance-enhancing substance. And thanks to the NFLPA, the required level for a "positive" finding is dropping - making the punishment of innocent players all the more certain.

Combined with government-mandated suspensions of the proposed length, the end result of a stricter testing regime in any sport is to bar players for life who have done nothing but train to the best of their ability. If avoiding that situation is reason for criticism, then good on the NHL for being criticized.

Wednesday, July 27, 2005

Wilful blindness

Not surprisingly, the EPA tried to avoid releasing a study on the fact that fuel efficiency has actually dropped since the 1980s. The surprise here isn't the effort to suppress the truth, but the fact that the truth made it into the open:
With Congress poised for a final vote on the energy bill, the Environmental Protection Agency made an 11th-hour decision Tuesday to delay the planned release of an annual report on fuel economy...

The contents of the report show that loopholes in American fuel economy regulations have allowed automakers to produce cars and trucks that are significantly less fuel-efficient, on average, than they were in the late 1980's.

One more glaring example of how miserably voluntary-compliance models are bound to fail. But fortunately, in this case the public (and the decision-makers) are able to see the facts before the final call is made - not that it'll likely make too much difference to the Congressional negotiators who make a career out of ignoring inconvenient facts.

The same Times front web page also highlights a less-than-surprising story where just the opposite was true:
Senior military lawyers lodged vigorous and detailed dissents in early 2003 as an administration legal task force concluded that President Bush had authority as commander in chief to order harsh interrogations of prisoners at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba, newly disclosed documents show...

The confidential government deliberations over permissible interrogation techniques that ranged from August 2002 to April 2003 were prompted by a request from officers at Guantánamo. They said traditional practices were proving ineffective against one detainee, Mohamed al-Kahtani, believed to have been the planned 20th hijacker on Sept. 11, 2001. Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld approved a series of techniques in December 2002, only to rescind them temporarily after military lawyers complained...

Mr. Rumsfeld subsequently learned of the military lawyers' objections and that became a factor in his decision on April 16, 2003, to limit the permitted interrogation techniques.

The lesson here is that even as thorough a Bush lackey as Rumsfeld can occasionally be driven to make more reasonable decisions when presented with a better set of principles and options. Too bad that happens so rarely.

Making use of information

With terrorism back on the front pages this month, here's a little reminder that the Bush administration's focus on Iraq is diverting attention from real intelligence issues:
The Federal Bureau of Investigation's backlog of untranslated terrorism intelligence doubled last year, and the time it takes the bureau to hire translators has grown longer...

(T)he F.B.I. "has no assurance" that some 8,300 hours of untranslated material does not include information that could be critical to terrorism investigations.

In addition, the bureau told the committee that its long-delayed effort to overhaul its computer system and allow agents to search terrorism files more easily would not be completed until 2009 at the earliest...

The F.B.I. met its hiring targets in fewer than half of 52 languages examined, and the average time it takes to hire a linguist grew from 13 months to at least 14 months, according to the bureau's data. The inspector general's office said its assessment showed that the average time was 16 months, with much of the delay blamed on applicants "waiting in queue" because of bureaucratic slowdowns.

Almost makes you wonder whether the FBI could have made any use of people fired because of prejudice. Or whether $200 billion could have been used to reduce the hiring backlog.

Freer information

Saskatchewan's information commissioner proposed in a ruling today that information requests should be free where made for a "compelling public interest", a standard currently present in most provinces.

I'd agree with that step, but the progress shouldn't stop there. Ultimately, information should generally be available for free unless there's particular expense or difficulty involved in putting it together.

Effectively, the "compelling public interest" should be presumed: a province or country is best off where its citizens look carefully at the government's activities, and there shouldn't be a financial penalty for reasonable efforts to do so.

The ongoing inquiry

The Arar inquiry is back, and it's getting interesting again:
The assistant commissioner of the RCMP instructed staff to withhold key information from Canada's foreign minister about their investigation into a Canadian citizen allegedly tortured in a Syrian jail...

Former foreign affairs minister Bill Graham asked for a thorough briefing by RCMP after then-U.S. ambassador Paul Cellucci suggested Maher Arar's deportation by U.S. authorities to Syria was based on Canadian intelligence.

But in an Oct. 18, 2002 memo that was read at the Arar inquiry, Richard Proulx informed the RCMP commissioner "there will be no information of an operational-tactical nature released to (Foreign Affairs)."...

The RCMP's deputy commissioner for operations, Garry Loeppky, defended the decision, saying day-to-day operational decisions, tactics employed and evidence are of no concern to Foreign Affairs.

Now, it may have helped to actually listen to Foreign Affairs in making that decision. In Graham's earlier testimony, he said that he believed the RCMP and CSIS when they each denied any involvement in Arar's rendition, but that he was frustrated in trying to get information.

The released memo makes it clear that this was the result of deliberate policy rather than a mere oversight. Heads should be rolling over that call; we'll see how long it takes for that to happen.

Nutrition and the environment

The Tyee points out one of the less-recognized effects of global warming, as our food now may be less nutritious as a result of the air around it:
A small but growing body of research is finding that elevated levels of atmospheric carbon dioxide, while increasing crop yield, decrease the nutritional value of plants. More than a hundred studies, for example, have found that when CO2 from fossil-fuel burning builds up in plant tissues, nitrogen (essential for making protein) declines. A smaller number of studies hint at another troubling impact: As atmospheric CO2 levels go up, trace elements in plants (such as zinc and iron, which are vital to animal and human life) go down, potentially malnourishing all those that subsist on the plants...

The less-nutritious plants of a CO2-enriched world will likely not be a problem for rich nations, where "super-sized" meals and vitamin supplements are a dietary mainstay. But things could be very different in the developing world, where millions already live on the edge of starvation, and where the micronutrient deficit, known as "hidden hunger," is already considered one of the world's leading health problems by the United Nations.

Food for thought. This is one more way in which the environment is fundamentally a health issue - and one more way in which that link has been sorely neglected.

And it begins...maybe

Just last month, Bush and Jaafari decried the possibility of a quick U.S. pullout.

Now, with Rumsfeld at his side, Jaafari is planning for just that:
Prime Minister Ibrahim Jaafari said at a joint news conference with U.S. Defence Secretary Donald Rumsfeld that the time has arrived to plan a co-ordinated transition from American to Iraqi military control throughout the country.

Asked how soon a U.S. withdrawal should happen, he said no exact timetable had been set. “But we confirm and we desire speed in that regard..."

Meanwhile, the U.S. is setting one problematic condition on withdrawal:
General George Casey, the top American commander in Iraq, said he believed a U.S. troop withdrawal could begin by spring 2006 if progress continues on the political front and if the insurgency does not expand.

If the apparent size of the insurgency will be the determining factor as to whether the U.S. stays, there are two possible results, neither of them a positive. Either insurgents could pick up the pace of attacks now to try to ensure that their best basis for recruitment remains in the country, or they could call off activity for now (perhaps infiltrating the Iraqi police forces even further) and be able to cause all the more mayhem once the U.S. pulls out.

Essentially, the U.S. has said that it'll allow the insurgents to set the timing of a pullout. Needless to say, that's a power that won't be used for good.

Tuesday, July 26, 2005

Rule of lawlessness

Maybe blind support for U.S. troops isn't deserved after all:
A company of the California Army National Guard has been put on restricted duty and its battalion plunged into disarray amid allegations that soldiers engaged in misconduct in Iraq, including mistreatment of detainees and extortion from shopkeepers, according to military officials and members of the battalion...

Among the allegations now under investigation is that at least six soldiers from the battalion took part in a scheme to extort money from Iraqi shopkeepers, apparently in exchange for protection from insurgents.

The payments allegedly exceeded $30,000, two sources said, and were made in U.S. currency, according to one member of the battalion who has been briefed on the investigation. Another soldier said the scheme allegedly was carried out during night patrols in the Baghdad area.

I suppose it's ultimately the result of the U.S. exporting its governance systems. But this can't be doing any good for Iraqis' collective view of the occupiers, or for their motivation to try to build a corruption-free society in the long term.

Public-Private Parity

Whenever there's a privatization movement afoot, much of the claim in favour focuses on how it's supposed to involve less expense - particularly when public-sector workers are replaced by private-sector ones with less effective unions. That has its downside too, when the less desirable job conditions lead to concurrently weaker workers.

The OPSEU is managing to avoid the expected results:
Correctional officers employed at Canada's only private adult jail have rejected the employer's final offer for a new collective agreement. Members of the Ontario Public Service employees Union Local 369 voted 95 per cent to reject the offer. Over 88 per cent of the employees turned out for the vote, held July 21...

Currently, workers at the facility run by Utah-based Management and Training Corporation earn two per cent less per hour than their public sector counterparts and receive fewer benefits and less time off. Sean Wilson, chair of the union bargaining team, says his members are united in this fight.

"The status quo is unacceptable," Wilson said. "We want the same as public sector correctional officers - period."

An excellent move by the union members to avoid a race-to-the-bottom situation - the province will surely make the same demand in the opposite direction (under penalty of further privatization) if the workers accept less now. And it's impressive to see such high numbers of members involved given the supposed malaise surrounding the union movement.

The ball is back in Superjail's court now. Stay tuned...

Resource discovery

Great news from northern Saskatchewan:
Northern Saskatchewan could soon be home to one of the first "rare earth" mineral mines in North America.

The 15 minerals considered "rare earth" are used in numerous products in the electronics industry, including MRIs, TV screens, rechargeable batteries and hydrogen-powered cars...

Industry analysts say this could be the beginning of a growing industry for Saskatchewan.

What has them excited is that all 15 minerals have been found together in abundance at a site just north of Uranium City.

The article notes that 80% of the world's current production of these minerals comes from China. A Saskatchewan deposit would be more convenient to the North American and European markets, making it a potential boon both for Saskatchewan itself, and for Canadian, American and European industries needing the supplies.

This is early going - but it's a very promising start.

Vote Canada: Now More Than Ever

Canada puts forward an interesting idea on Security Council reform:
Canada tabled a proposal Tuesday to create 20 temporary spots for elected members, in addition to the five permanent ones established after the Second World War. Holding elections would make the world organization more accountable and democratic, Canada's UN ambassador argued.

Rock said "permanence is the polar opposite of accountability." Instead, he proposed creating 20 regionally based memberships and allowing countries in each region - Africa, for instance - to regularly elect their representatives.

I doubt this proposal will get very far; the emerging powers won't want to lose the possibility of a permanent seat, the current SC members won't want to risk an organized and hostile majority on the Council, and smaller countries probably won't see it as the most desirable possible reform based on the obvious risk that their anticipated voting bloc wouldn't win out.

But I'd be very curious to see how such a system would work if implemented. Presumably one of two things would happen: either the current regional powers (India, Germany, Japan, Brazil, Nigeria, etc.) would strong-arm their way to effectively permanent seats; or, the regional powers would consider that to be less than the best possible use of their international capital, leaving softer powers (likely including Canada) to fill the spots.

Either way, this would be the most interesting election process on the face of the planet. For that reason alone, the proposal is worth a look.

Learning lessons

It wasn't part of U.S. policy when it came to Iraq, but where North Korea is concerned sovereignty is assumed:
Six-party nuclear disarmament talks opened Tuesday after a 13-month boycott by North Korea, and the communist nation's envoy said his country was ready to work on eliminating atomic weapons from the Korean Peninsula....

North Korea agreed to return to the talks following a meeting earlier this month between Kim and the main U.S. envoy, Assistant Secretary of State Christopher Hill, who assured the North that Washington recognized its sovereignty.

On Tuesday, Hill repeated those pledges.

"We view (North Korea's) sovereignty as a matter of fact. The United States has absolutely no intention to invade or attack" North Korea, Hill said in his opening remarks.

It's great to see some progress being made. Funny how it's easier to make gains through diplomacy when there's actual conversation rather than a series of demands and threats.

On encouraging progress

This is precisely the type of new idea that governments should be encouraging on the road to sustainable development:
All Marcelo da Luz wants is to drive his solar car across the country.

His dream car, designed and built with the help of a few professionals over the last six years. The one he mortgaged his house for and spent $200,000 on; the one that proves -- to himself anyway -- that any goal is attainable...

Mr. da Luz...has taken the last two years off work to complete the "Power of One'' solar car, a low-riding, flying-saucer-like vehicle powered by the 893 solar cells that cover most of its surface. It's five metres long by 1.8 metres wide and 90 centimetres deep. It can reach speeds of up to 120 kilometres an hour on the same amount of energy that powers a toaster.

The problem is that Ontario refuses to license the car, and other jurisdictions (with the exceptions of Saskatchewan and the Yukon, both of whom have granted permits) are following its lead.

The explanation is that a student was killed in a traffic accident as part of a solar car tour. The article doesn't mention whether there were differences in engineering between the different types of solar cars, and there's no indication at all that Ontario has made an effort to determine what could make da Luz' car fit to be licensed. Instead the (already stringent) conditions previously set on solar vehicles are under review.

For now, a great idea sits idle simply because it isn't the norm. With any luck, the public attention will force Ontario to look at how to let da Luz go forward; if not, then we'll have been told all definitively that Ontario isn't willing to do its part to help its citizens innovate.

Monday, July 25, 2005

Did someone feel a chill?

From the Boston Globe:

The U.S. Democrats show an unusual amount of backbone...
Democrats, who have urged Bush to fire Rove or revoke his classified clearance, stepped up political pressure on Republicans on Monday by calling for a formal congressional investigation of the Plame leak.

"The United States Congress has a constitutional responsibility to provide oversight of the executive branch, whether a law has been broken or not," the 26 senators said in a letter.

...and are rewarded with self-serving Republican politicking sinking to remarkable depths:
(Pat Roberts spokeswoman Sarah) Little said the Senate committee would also review the probe of special prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald, who has been investigating the Plame case for nearly two years.

While the committee will ostensibly be investigating the behaviour of the White House as the primary goal, it isn't hard to see where this is going.

Will Republicans Fitzgerald and Larry Johnson be slammed for partisanship against Bushco? Will the "national security" angle be used to tighten up legitimate flows of information rather than to demand accountability from political leakers?

And are the answers so obvious that it's not even worth asking the questions?

(Via Daily Kos.)

Edit: The Suburban Guerrilla points out a comment on Kos suggesting that the Republicans will grant full immunity to the White House staff under investigation. Rove may well have some tricks up his sleeve yet.

New poll results

Harper's summer swing doesn't appear to be doing much for the Conservatives. From Decima Research:
Nationally, the poll placed the Liberals at 39 per cent of decided voters, compared with 24 per cent for the Conservatives and 19 per cent for the NDP.

The national numbers are based on Decima's weekly national poll of 1,000 Canadians conducted July 14-17.

While the Star focuses on the Quebec results (which show the Liberals making up some ground against the Bloc with both the NDP and the Cons in single digits), the national numbers are the more interesting ones from my standpoint.

There's little doubt that the Liberals have a solid lead on all comers at this point; however, this is one more poll to add to the pile where the NDP is within striking distance of the Cons. Of course there are others which have included double-digit gaps.

But at this point, a fluid electorate is probably the best situation for the NDP, particularly if it's based on dissatisfaction with Harper and company. Based on the new numbers, the electorate is both fluid, and flowing (slightly) in the right direction.

A strong opinion

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has issued its opinion on the cattle injunction - and it doesn't leave much room for discussion:
The high court said Cebull should have respected the judgment and expertise of the agriculture department about safety risks instead of blithely accepting the word of R-CALF.

R-CALF, said the three judges, didn't show a likelihood of success on the merits of its case, which centred on arguments that Canadian cattle pose extensive risks to U.S. herds and human health, as well as "irreparable economic harm."

"The record does not support the district court's alarmist findings (of harm) from the stigma of Canadian beef will actually befall the American beef industry," said the Court of Appeals...

"Instead of evaluating the (mad cow) safeguards as part of a larger system, the district court parsed the regulations and faulted USDA for any risk that a given step failed to remove," said the opinion.

R-CALF doesn't want to give up, but it's tough to see how there could be any merit to a hearing on a permanent injunction at this point.

(I'll keep an eye out for an HTML copy of the opinion for further commentary - drop a comment if you spot one.)

Corporate censorship

Via The Coast of Bohemia, Boing Boing points out an appalling move by Telus:
The Telecommunications Workers' Union of Canada has been locked out by Telus, a large phone company and ISP. Two of TWU's sites (including Voices for Change, a message board where union members can discuss issues such as being without a contract for 1666 days and last having received a general wage increase 2031 days ago).

Telus is playing very dirty -- they're blocking access to the union's website so that their workers and the general public are cut off from legitimate debate about this action. This is inexcusable: imagine if this phone company chose to block all calls into union headquarters.

Indeed. The Coast of Bohemia offers links to the CRTC and Telus' complaints page - stop by and make it clear that the censorship won't be ignored.

Taking control

There's ample coverage of the dispute between Canada and Denmark over Hans Island. But before asking whether Canada should be making claims to new territory, let's ask whether Canada has done all that well handling another relatively recent addition. A new film suggests otherwise:
In 1944, Iceland, a desperately poor place, became independent from Denmark. Five years later, Newfoundlanders went in the opposite direction and voted to join Canada...

Debate ensues on the issue of provincial autonomy and how natural resources such as fish, oil and nickel have been exported to other places for processing and refining. Manufacturing of finished goods, consequently, also takes place elsewhere.

Iceland, with its similar terrain, is shown as having a lifestyle quite to the contrary. Small shops owned by Icelanders are shown vs. the big box stores of Canada. No mansions or great displays of wealth are seen. Three hundred thousand tourists visit each year. With a population of 280,000 people, Iceland publishes 1,000 books per year.

Of course, Newfoundland chose its course, and hopefully it will take some steps economically thanks to the Atlantic accord. But there should be no doubt that Canada's parental attitude has had a negative effect - and that we're still a good ways away from doing the most possible for the territory we already have.

Sunday, July 24, 2005

Non-thinking caps

A new movement is afoot in the U.S. to try to tie the hands of governments - even though the one current example has been a miserable failure:
A spending restraint initiative is also expected to appear on the November ballot in Ohio, where a signature gathering effort is wrapping up. By 2006, Maine and Oregon residents probably will vote on similar proposals.

Meanwhile, in Georgia, Missouri, Tennessee and Wisconsin, spending cap bills are picking up significant support in legislatures. And as lawmakers elsewhere continue to balk at such proposals — they have come up in 23 state legislatures this year but have not passed in any of them — activists are planning to go directly to the ballot in many of those places...

Colorado is bucking the trend. There, a decade-old cap threatens to squeeze state spending so much that Republican Gov. Bill Owens and leaders of the state's business community are imploring voters to pass an initiative on the fall ballot that would lift the cap for five years.

The evidence from Colorado supports what seem to be obvious intuitive problems with measures like these. Rather than paying the slightest bit of attention to the needs within a state, the caps set out an arbitrary top level, leaving all interests within the state to fight against each other for funding. It doesn't matter if a one-year investment at the right time can lead to a better long-term fiscal situation (say, a large infrastructure expense in support of expected development) - the government simply doesn't have the choice.

Never mind running government like a business; instead the government runs like a business which knows that it's prevented from expanding or investing. Which is another phrase for a business that's in trouble.

The cap movement is led by groups which effectively assume that any government spending is too much; this is never a safe assumption. But even where excessive government spending exists, the proper means of dealing with it is through a better government making better decisions with an eye to the long term, not through artificial caps which necessitate governance based on surviving the short term. Colorado has learned the hard way, and it may not be long before more states do the same.

As for Canada, we lack much of the basis for such restrictions in any event: most Canadian budgets are already under much better control than those to the south, and there's more political will for careful budgets thanks to the parliamentary system. But we should learn from the U.S.' mistakes, and make sure not to let any efforts for similar measures get near the Canadian political scene.

Boilerplate

Let it never be said that the Iraq war hasn't led to some progress. For example, the U.S. military's PR department is getting much more efficient:
Following a car bombing in Baghdad on Sunday, the U.S. military issued a statement with a quotation attributed to an unidentified Iraqi that was virtually identical to a quote reacting to an attack on July 13...

Sunday's news release said: "'The terrorists are attacking the infrastructure, the ISF and all of Iraq. They are enemies of humanity without religion or any sort of ethics. They have attacked my community today and I will now take the fight to the terrorists,' said one Iraqi man who preferred not to be identified."

The July 13 news release said: "'The terrorists are attacking the infrastructure, the children and all of Iraq,' said one Iraqi man who preferred not to be identified. 'They are enemies of humanity without religion or any sort of ethics. They have attacked my community today and I will now take the fight to the terrorists.'"

In fairness, we shouldn't rush to conclusions. Sure, it looks like the military is inventing quotes, or at least reusing them. But there's at least some chance that both quotations are from Chalabi associates who merely remembered their lines a little too well.

It doesn't take a rocket scientist

NASA's new line: the same unexplained problem that put off the last planned Discovery launch now isn't worth worrying about.
At an evening news conference, Hale and other NASA officials found themselves defending the decision to launch with a fuel gauge failure. They stressed that they will proceed with a liftoff only if the problem is well understood and involves the gauges in question - anything else will result in a postponement...

NASA Administrator Michael Griffin said he supports the decision and even hopes the problem recurs to further pinpoint the source of the trouble. He acknowledged that the public might perceive that the space agency is rushing to launch, but insisted it was the right technical judgment.

If NASA wants the problem to recur so as to be able to better figure out its nature, wouldn't that suggest that it's something less than well understood?

At the moment, the administrators are trying to justify going ahead against public pressure to the contrary. But how much stronger will that public pressure be if Discovery meets the same fate as Columbia? This may well be the end of the line for the current shuttle program - and with that at stake NASA seems willing to launch on hope rather than anything approaching knowledge.

Humanitarian program at work

Tales from the UK's Home Office:
Asylum seekers were being rejected if they had not sought medical treatment after alleged brutalities, even if they lived in war zones where it was impossible to get medical help, she said.

One applicant was told that an attack they had suffered, in which others had died, was so bad that 'it is not believed that you would have been able to survive'. Others were turned down on the basis of assumptions of what officers thought they might do themselves in the circumstances...

'The examples cited in the report of refusals made by Home Office caseworkers are jaw-dropping, but what is truly shocking is that the report contains so many of them,' said a spokeswoman. 'The report paints a picture of a system dominated by a "culture of disbelief", in which refusals are the norm and stories of persecution are only ever accepted grudgingly.'...

For some nationalities, such as Somalians and Eritreans, more than a third of those rejected have the decision overturned on appeal. The Refugee Council spokeswoman said that unless decisions were made clearly and fairly in the first place, the government would struggle to reduce delays in the system and speed up removals.

The article notes that the public debate over immigration has helped to poison the immigration process. It's easy to point out an individual refugee who wound up harming a society - it's much more difficult to point out the potential contributions of would-be refugees who were turned away, or the suffering of somebody who ends up being persecuted after being sent back to a repressive state. But the latter two factors far outweigh the former, and it looks like the UK has been turning away deserving arrivals due to a lack of understanding of that point.

Let them eat cake

Conservative MP Helena Guergis demands that Canada stop giving aid to China, based primarily on the fact that China itself has enough wealth to build up a large army and a space program.

There's an obvious counterbalance to those considerations:
(T)he Canadian International Development Agency says aid to China is necessary because, despite its progress, it still contains 20 per cent of the world's poor and "some of the earth's most severe environmental problems."

Inequality between rural and urban areas, particularly in western China where women and ethnic minorities are "disproportionately affected," means "targeted measures are needed to address these imbalances."

While China probably does have enough resources to take care of its own if it so chose, it should be plainly obvious that the priorities of the Chinese regime lie elsewhere. Canada's choice is thus between either neglecting the Chinese poor entirely, or offering enough aid to allow them to at least survive, and potentially to have a role in reshaping the state in the longer term.

One would think that if reform is our goal, then our policy should ensure that potential reformers have the means and opportunity to be heard. One would then be thinking a lot more clearly than Helena Guergis.

Shocking

It's official. Tehran is now home to more accountability than Washington:
In an unprecedented report, Iran's hard-line judiciary Sunday acknowledged widespread human rights violations in prisons, including use of torture and solitary confinement, state-run media reported Sunday.

The report, which was broadcast by state-run radio Sunday, said prison guards and officials in detention centers have ignored a legal order banning torture. It also said police have made several arrests without sufficient evidence and held suspects in undeclared detention centers.

The report also made the front covers of both state-run and privately-run newspapers. It's pleasantly surprising to see what seems to be a fairly spontaneous move toward letting the truth out.

Of course, the "not following orders" defence is suspicious, but at least it's not accompanied by the "only enemies want to expose our crimes" view of the Bush administration.

Saturday, July 23, 2005

On recognizing the problem

Gerard Latortue may extend Haiti's voter registration deadline due to low turnout. But he figures the problem is late registration, rather than the obvious explanation:
Latortue said he was optimistic at least one million people would register by the end of July, adding his goal is to see at least 2.5 million registered.

"My experience in Haiti is that people always wait until the last moment to register," he said...

Aristide supporters have also suggested many citizens are not interested in voting because his Lavalas Family party has so far not agreed to participate, an argument the interim government has dismissed.

The reality is that the last man repeatedly elected by the Haitian populace is now in exile, and his party successor is now in jail based on demonstrations by his opponents rather than on anything resembling evidence:
Rev. Gerard Jean-Juste, who has emerged as a possible Lavalas presidential contender, was sent to prison and told he could be charged in connection with the slaying of a prominent Haitian journalist...

Authorities said they detained Jean-Juste for questioning because of a "public clamour" for his arrest by angry demonstrators at the journalist's funeral Thursday.

To Latortue's credit, he hasn't acted on the insane suggestion that Lavalas be formally banned. But it should be obvious that whatever comes out of the next Haitian poll, it won't in any meaningful way resemble "fair and representative elections". By Latortue's own standards, failure is inevitable - and extending the deadline won't change that.

Deconstruction

Here's how well Iraq's constitutional process is working at the moment:
The now 14-person Sunni delegation suspended its participation in the constitution draft process after a 15th committee member, Mijbil Ali Hussein al-Sheikh Issa, was shot and killed in Baghdad earlier this week. Two other people, including a consultant to the committee, were also killed.

The delegation wants better security and an international probe into the deaths, said the Western official, who told reporters the Sunnis have expressed doubts about the credibility of an Interior Ministry probe.

Does anybody seriously think that genuine agreement on a constitution is close to happening when the entire Sunni delegation doubts the credibility of the current regime which is happily getting into bed with Iran? There may well be an "agreed" constitution by the deadline, but it's obvious that there's no real trust between even the major factions, and that's with both former Baathists and religious extremists mostly left out of the process. The mess keeps getting worse, and will keep doing so no matter how long the U.S. chooses to stick around.

Fair and balanced

Not that there's any surprise, but CanWest goes off the rails again. The National Post concludes that what Canada needs is a love letter to conservatism in general, framed around questions about Stephen Harper's leadership.

While a good chunk of the article is spent fawning over Harper or giving him tons of unopposed quote space, the more remarkable angle is that the article manages to include multiple dissenting voices against Harper without giving a word's worth of mention to non-Conservatives. Critical quotes come from Harper's recent biographer, a Conservative member saying that Harper hasn't mentioned policy enough, and another party member who notes that Harper managed to drive his wife and daughter out of the party. The undercurrent is that Harper's views are to be taken as correct; the only question posed is whether Harper can successfully impose those views on Canada.

But nowhere is there the slightest hint that there could be another alternative to the Liberals...nor even that the Liberals themselves are anything more than a placeholder waiting to be removed as soon as the chosen Con leads his party to victory.

Of course, if there's any party trying to fight against "stubborn polling numbers", it's the party which hasn't risen much in the polls despite having the country's most credible leader and a track record of accomplishing its goals in Parliament, not the one which has dropped in the polls because it's been embroiled in scandal while accomplishing nothing. Somehow I doubt the NDP will get the chance to make its case through the NP's featured story.

Friday, July 22, 2005

Foreign policy contradictions

Via Rabble, This Magazine has a rundown of Canada's allegedly two-faced foreign policy:
Situation: Vietnam War
What we said: Prime Minister Lester B. Pearson publicly called for a pause in bombing and a negotiated settlement to the Vietnam War.
What we did: The Canadian military participated in the conflict and also profited by supplying US forces with a range of lethal and non-lethal supplies, from boots and bombs to berets and Agent Orange.

The analysis is simplistic (as would tend to be the case given a ratio of two sentences per foreign policy issue), but the concept is one worth considering in more detail.

The most significant problem with the article is that it makes no distinction between government policy and private actors. In some cases such as Vietnam and Iraq, the hypocrisy was genuinely within the government itself; the same is probably true for South Africa where the calls for a boycott weren't backed by policy.

That said, there's no inherent contradiction in seeking to change a state's human rights record while at the same time allowing (or even encouraging) trade - particularly where the effect of that trade is to open up the society to at least some degree, which is a possibility in at least some circumstances.

Of course we shouldn't be looking to boost trade where the effect will be to prop up apartheid-type regimes or to fuel a civil war - and the article is able to mention a few such cases. But we should be aware of the potential for freer trade to bring with it a freer flow of ideas, and seek out opportunities to encourage both, through both our government and our private sector.

Points for brazenness

Now Bushco isn't even pretending to be the least bit accountable for anything:
The White House on Thursday threatened to veto a massive Senate bill for $442 billion in next year's defense programs if it moves to regulate the Pentagon's treatment of detainees or sets up a commission to investigate operations at Guantanamo Bay prison and elsewhere.

The Bush administration, under fire for the indefinite detention of enemy combatants at Guantanamo Bay in Cuba and questions over whether its policies led to horrendous abuses at Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq, put lawmakers on notice it did not want them legislating on the matter.

The Bush strategy is now clear: hire Halliburton to provide the world's largest rug on a no-bid, cost-plus basis, and start sweeping as frantically as humanly possible.

But with prominent Republicans refusing to play along (and neither McCain nor Graham was buying the White House line), this isn't going to work. As well it shouldn't.

(Via Kos and Digby.)

Flying under the radar

For those wondering whether coordination with the U.S.' no-fly list would be that big a deal from an information standpoint: yes, it would be:
The U.S. Transportation Security Administration violated privacy laws by secretly collecting personal information on at least 250,000 people, congressional investigators said Friday.

The Government Accountability Office sent a letter to Congress saying the collection violated the Privacy Act, which prohibits the government from compiling information on people without their knowledge...

The GAO letter noted the TSA also said originally it wouldn't use and store commercial data about airline passengers. It not only did that, it collected and stored information about the people with similar names.

The information-gathering might well have been reasonable if disclosed in advance, though the "similar names" part of the project seems like a ready recipe for a lot more Brandon Mayfields based on even less evidence.

More importantly, though, do we really need more examples of how much contempt the current U.S. administration has for both individual privacy and proper process in general?

Transit use

This press release doesn't give details of the nationwide increase, but this deserves some attention:
BC Transit's Municipal Systems Program carried a total of 18.6 million passengers in 2004/05, an increase of 841,000 (5%)over the previous year. This is more than double the 2.4% increase in ridership posted by transit systems across Canada. The program includes 69 transit systems across British Columbia outside Greater Vancouver and Victoria.

I'd be interested to see the source of the nationwide numbers, and of course a breakdown of where the increases were the greatest. In any event, it's great news that (even before the added money for transit this year) people are making better use of an environmentally-friendly option.

Just wondering...

Billmon slams the new and all-the-more-depraved Patriot Act. A good read.

In light of Harper's endorsement of every other current U.S. initiative, has anybody asked him whether he thinks Canada should follow this one?

About time

Ontario announces funding to allow for $4 billion in school repairs:
Under the "good places to learn" program, the province will provide $280 million over three years for school boards. That money will allow them to obtain $4 billion in loans to repair, upgrade and replace old schools.

The initiative and the funding was announced in February. Yesterday, Kennedy outlined how this year's money — $75 million from the province, to obtain $1 billion for repairs in 1,400 schools — would be spent.

But the funding doesn't come close to covering the backlog of needed repairs.

Toronto Catholic board chair Oliver Carroll recently told the Toronto Star that it would take $5 billion to $6 billion over 15 years just to make Toronto's 750 public and separate schools state-of-the-art buildings.

As important as it was to balance budgets in the '90s, this is the fallout, as needed capital expenditures are over a decade behind schedule. Fortunately, some provinces are using the spoils of good fiscal management to catch up on these projects. Kudos to McGuinty for joining the list.